I am looking for a nice restaurant in the Columbus area to take my wife to a surprise date to. I'm looking for it to meet the criteria below

-Close to Easton,  this one isn't really a big deal but its where we are staying

-Nice restaurant, like have to wear a tie

-nothing so pricey that i need a black credit card to pay

-I also dont want it to be a place you must have a reservation, a wait is fine though

Usually I would google but i think i would get better result asking the people who actually live in Columbus