I thought we could use a Halloween-themed forum today, and considering the success of the "Favorite Band" thread, I thought this could be fun.
I think it makes sense to have chocolate and non-chocolate categories.
Chocolate: Reese's - the classic peanut butter cup, with honorable mention to 100 Grand and Hershey's Special Dark with Almonds.
Non-chocolate: Zagnut - hard to find, but love the peanut butter crunch with the toasted coconut. Also fond of Payday.
Of course, the king of all candies is the Buckeye, but I consider that more of a homemade confection and a year-round treat than a Halloween candy.
What about you?