Wishing Braxton the best of Luck

ziplock007's picture
November 9, 2011 at 9:00p
5 Comments

According to ESPN's NFL Analyst, the two greatest things in the world (in order) are Andrew Luck and Sliced Bread.  There are too few superlatives in their lexicon to describe his greatness.  There has never been a pro prospect with as much potential as Andrew Luck.  He is so good, they cannot classify his greatness... get the point?

Meanwhile, OSU is stuck with a pittance of a passing offense.  Fans are just happy if a pass is attempted once every five minutes.  Let's do the impossible and compare a non-Andrew-Luck speciman (Braxton Miller) to the scrumtrulescent Andrew Luck.

In six starts (half a season) he's thrown 74 attempts and harbors a completion rate of 51% with 6 TDs and e Ints.  Extrapolate that out to a 12 game schedule (umm, multiply by 2) and we have a projected stat line of 148 attempts with 12 TDs to 6 picks.  Definitely pathetic when compared to Andrew Luck; this explains why OSU has a running oriented offense.

How did Andrew Luck fare his true freshman year?  He didn't play.  That's right, the greatest thing in the history of all things was sentenced to the bench.  What did his second year wraught in 2009?  A paltry 56% completion rate and a Braxtonesque 13 to 4 TD to Int ratio.  All this in a conference not known for the defense.  Remember the RB Heisman candidate Tony Gerhart?  He was the core of the Stanford offense; yep, like Braxton's first year, the offense revolved around the run.  And, even with a future NFL MVP at QB, a future NFL coach (Harbaugh) and a future NFL RB, Stanford finished 2009 with a mediocre 8-5 record and 4th in the Pac-10.

Even the great QB draft picks take time to develop.  Yes, Braxton will be lucky to end up with double digit touchdowns, but so was a second year Andrew Luck.  There's only 4 teams in the nation starting True Freshman QBs, three are terrible and one is in Big Ten title contention.  OSU won the 2008 Big Ten during Pryor's true Freshman year; I challenge you readers (because I'm too lazy to look this up) to find the last time a BCS team won its conference with a true freshman at the helm.

Stop complaining about the excessive runs, Braxton is doing just fine.  Let's wish him the best of Luck.

(by the way, if anyone knows what scrumtrulescent means Will Ferrell will be proud)


Join me next week when I compare Joe Bauserman's value to Andrew Luck's.  I may need help.

Comments

Buckeye in Athens's picture

Just wanted to say +1. Good perspective. 

flipbuckeye's picture

Join me next week when I compare Joe Bauserman's value to Andrew Luck's.

You might break the Internet.

Buckeyejason's picture

You're comparing this years #1 pick and a guy who's carring an elite ACADEMIC school with high admission standards to possibly a National Chamionship... to a player who..will be good/great in college but probably won't be drafted in the 1st 5 rounds when all is said and done, playing on a team full of 4 and 5 star recruits?

Apples and Oranges.

And I believe Luck didn't play as a freshman because he had a future NFL QB in front of him..the names not ringing a bell but he was drafted by the Bills.

BUCKEYES BABY!

Buckeyejason's picture

Edit: I apologize that QB left Stanford before Luck arrived.

BUCKEYES BABY!

Goose's picture

How many attempts did Luck have his sophomore year compared to what Braxton has this year?  My biggest concern is that he isn't getting the experience throwing the ball that he needs to develop that part of his game.