Pleasant Surprises

By Michael Citro on October 13, 2013 at 10:30a
Kenny G: always good, but never previously THIS good.

At the halfway point of the regular season, it’s useful to look back and take stock of what has transpired through Ohio State’s first six games.

This is the time of year you’ll see report cards, stories tracking statistical projections, midseason reviews, and other such journalistic enterprises. These are particularly prevalent when, as in 2013, the mid-season point coincides with a Buckeye bye week.

I’m not immune to the tricks of the trade. I too am prone to critical appraisal of the happenings in the college football season to date. One of my favorite exercises is to examine reality and compare it to my initial expectations, just to see where the cream has unexpectedly risen to the top. As you may imagine, it’s a very positive activity and serves up a heaping helping of the warm and fuzzies as we head into the stretch run.

Herein, I’ll discuss the players that have pleasantly surprised me by exceeding any and all of my own personal expectations. While your mileage may vary, these are the guys that have blown up my preconceived notions of what their contributions to the success of Ohio State football would be in 2013:

6. Chris Carter

If you had told me before the season that sophomore defensive lineman Chris Carter would be on the field for meaningful snaps, I would have assumed things weren’t going well. I’d have figured he was playing right tackle after a rash of offensive line injuries. It turns out the 6-foot-4, (down to) 340-pound Cleveland product has found a niche on the D-line.

In his second season, Carter has looked comfortable at nose tackle, eating up blocks, freeing up his teammates to make plays and even showing some quickness for a man his size. He has only seven tackles on the season, but the linebackers and safeties provide most of the stops for the Buckeyes anyway. Carter also has a tackle for loss, a sack and a fumble recovery to his credit this year.

Where there was once just a massive lump of potential, there is now the makings of a future star in Carter, which makes him one of the biggest (and best) surprises of the season so far.

5. Michael Bennett

Large man. Large beard.Carter began the year as an afterthought. Now he plays.

Don’t get me wrong, I knew Bennett had talent and could make plays. The junior from Centerville has shown flashes of greatness in an OSU career sometimes sidetracked by injuries.  He appeared in eight games last season, finishing with 11 tackles, a TFL, a sack and a fumble recovery. He was a key reserve (when healthy) behind a senior-laden defensive line that also featured early NFL entrant Johnathan Hankins.

Bennett has become the leader of his unit this season, showing previously unseen speed and explosiveness from his defensive tackle position. Despite missing a game already this year, Bennett has 12 tackles, 3.5 TFLs, two sacks and two fumble recoveries. He blows up offensive linemen, clogs running lanes, provides pressure on opposing passers, and gives his teammates a spark.

If Ohio State is going to challenge for conference and national crowns, Michael Bennett will likely be one of the most significant contributors to the cause.

4. Evan Spencer

The junior wideout from Vernon Hills, Ill., caught 12 passes a year ago, gaining 136 yards, of which 44 came on a single play. He did not score a touchdown. I thought Spencer to be full of potential but was starting to wonder if it would ever be realized.

In 2013, Spencer already has 11 catches for 110 yards and three touchdowns, showing a significant increase in production. More importantly, Spencer has been a key factor in Ohio State’s success in the run game. He has developed into an outstanding blocker and has been unselfish in providing room for his teammates to excel. When Urban Meyer speaks about the improvement in his receiving corps, I believe Spencer to be one of the people foremost in his mind.

He even specifically singled out Spencer after the Cal game for his performance.

3. Dontre Wilson

We may not have seen much of him in recent games, but Wilson has been a revelation in 2013. Every year, incoming freshmen enter with a lot of hype and buzz, only to get buried on the depth chart or redshirted, as they struggle to adjust to the speed of the college game, or to grasp all of the mental aspects of learning complicated systems while simultaneously figuring out how to live on their own — often far from home — and adjusting to courses at the university level.

With that in mind, I was understandably skeptical when I heard predictions of Wilson making an immediate impact with the Buckeyes in 2013. Boy, was I wrong.

The speedster out of DeSoto, Texas, has played in all six games so far, serving as the team’s primary kickoff return man. But his real impact has been out of the backfield, where he averages 9.5 yards every time he runs the ball (15/142), adding one touchdown. Wilson also has 11 receptions for 105 yards. He seems a threat to take it to the house every time he touches the ball. His raw abilities are so important that Tom Herman is trying to clean up the other aspects of Wilson’s game so he can be on the field more.

Of all Ohio State’s playmakers, he might have the highest ceiling.

2. Kenny Guiton

The smooth jazz against Purdue (that video never gets old), and in finishing various drives for Braxton Miller, made Kenny G a folk hero in 2012. I knew Guiton was a quality backup quarterback. What I didn’t know, was whether he could be part of game planning, be on the field from the first snap, and handle his team from start to finish.

I see you now, Kenny G.

Guiton was so effective in games against San Diego State, California and Florida A&M that some deluded few actually began to question whether or not Miller should return to the starting lineup (lookin’ at you, ESPN). Despite Guiton tossing a school-record 90-yard touchdown at Cal and setting a school mark with six scoring tosses in one half against Florida A&M there was never any real threat to Miller’s position as QB1.

What Guiton did was to rally the troops while their leader was sidelined, completing 68.4% of his passes (65/95) for 664 yards and 13 touchdowns, with just two interceptions. He also ran 25 times for 186 yards and a touchdown. A team with a lesser backup might have survived at home against cupcake opponents, but only a cool veteran leader could guide his team through a west coast trip without a hiccup.

1. Joey Bosa

Joey Bosa has not played like a true freshman in 2013.

If young playmakers like Wilson seldom make an impact their freshman year, it’s even more rare for a true frosh to compete immediately in big time college football on a physical level. Enter Joey Bosa.

With former NFL defensive linemen John Bosa and Eric Kumerow in the family tree, Ohio State’s 6-foot-6, 275-pound man child out of Fort Lauderdale, Fla., was built to play in the trenches. That he can do it right away and at a very high level is ludicrous.

Bosa has become one of the most important cogs in Mike Vrabel’s defensive line, with a quick first step, amazing brute force, and a nose for the football. Appearing in all six games, Bosa has 16 tackles, four TFLs, two sacks, a quarterback hurry and a fumble recovery for a touchdown.

I always felt Bosa would be one of the freshmen to flash in his first season. However, I never expected the impact we’ve seen so far. Buckeye fans should be excited to see how his career develops.

So those are my biggest stunners of the season so far. Who you got?


Comments Show All Comments

BKLYN_Buckeye's picture

Great list. I would add Curtis Grant. Despite some leaky pass protection plays, I think CG has played beyond my expectations. He's been a solid LB. 

InHartWeTrust's picture

Was going to post literally the exact same thing.  +1 to you my friend!

flipbuckeye's picture

Dude is a beast against the run. Nice to see him finally making some noise.

CC's picture

I would say he has been most effective when he blitzes.  He has the speed and size to cause a mess when he blitzes.
I agree thought I actually thought he would be benched by this point in the season and obviously I'm glad I was wrong.

causeicouldntgo43's picture

Ross's last defensive review (OSU v. NW) included some analysis of Grant in that game - good against the run, but still lost in translation when it comes to pass protection................

741's picture

Nice article.

rdubs's picture

Also good to see Bosa avoid concussion issues that plagued his senior year of high school.  I hope he makes it through the season without injury which would almost be equally impressive as his play given the physical nature of playing on the line (especially for a freshman).  

poop's picture

Bosa is definitely #1 on the list. I love how disruptive he is on passing plays but I really haven't paid attention to him on running plays.

CC's picture

Personally Bosa isn't that much of a surprise to me per se, but he has exceeded my expectations.  He has the best versatility of any of our D-Lineman as he's the only one I've noticed play all 4 positions.
The list is almost perfect, but if I were to change the list, I would remove Bennett because he has been consistently good when healthy so it isn't much of a surprise.  I would add Jamal Marcus because I didn't even expect to see him play much less contribute.  He has provided a spark several times this season with an aggressive rush from the edge.
I think all of our D-Line success can be at least somewhat attributed to Vrabel.  The D-Line has looked great since he has been back.

Abe Froman's picture

Cameron Johnston.  So far, so good with the Aussie and I think he has like 3 net return yards.  His average isn't high, but then he hasn't exactly been kicking from our own 20 yard line.  He definitely belongs on the list, although not top 3.

Basking in the wake of mediocrity.....

gumtape's picture

Eric kumerow was a linebacker. C'mon citro.

High and tight boo boo

bodast67's picture

With former NFL defensive linemen John Bosa and Eric Kumerow in the family tree

 Kumerow played LB and D-line @ TOSU but was drafted as a D-end by the Dolphins and played mostly on D-line as a pro. 




     " I hope when I die, I die laughing"...                

Michael Citro's picture

Miami played him as a 4-3 defensive end much like Ohio State uses Noah Spence. C'mon, gumtape

bodast67's picture

You just beat me to the facts Michael !




     " I hope when I die, I die laughing"...                

Scarlet_Lutefisk's picture

Earle also ran a 3-4 and Kumerow was usually lined up on the LOS.

gumtape's picture

Oh crap. And there I was just a few helmet stickers short of a premium membership.

High and tight boo boo

CALPOPPY's picture

Ha! Thanks for the LOL. Here's a sticker for your effort.

I'm a hurtin' buckaroo.

HighBallAce's picture

I think Ezekiel Elliot should possibly get an honorable mention! Kid has been solid when he's played and was a beast against Florida A&M. 

Hovenaut's picture

The best thing about this list is that, with the exception of Kenny G (aside from maybe a few encore performances this season), all these young men are likely coming back. 

Poison nuts's picture

Great list. I think it's spot on. I would also add in Jordan Hall. In the time he was in was pretty phenomenal, even if not against the greatest competition. I look forward to he & Hyde both getting carries soon & bet by the end of the year this team will be hitting on all cylinders & looking very powerful in the run game.

"Do not pass me, just slow down - I can move right through you" Superchunk - Precision Auto.

causeicouldntgo43's picture

For me, Spencer has been the most pleasant surprise. He has elevated his game not only when he gets the ball, but when he doesn't, and has to execute blocks.

balbak buck's picture

I am surprised as to why not giving KG more playing time .Its not unheard of to play two Qbacks.And he will not challange Braxton.He is leaving next year and Braxton,IMO,is staying.The guy paid his dues and stayed for now 5 years.Why not give him a chance to shine a bit and maybe get drafted.Those who talk about his arm strength are wrong..not all good QBs in NFL have great arm strength.But all do have a good command and can manage the Game.I think Braxton is a better over all but KG deserve his shot to make it to the next level.

SOF_Buckeye's picture

Somewhere on list should be Taylor Decker. Aside from the first game, he has been will beyon solid at the RT.

"The harder you work, the harder it is to surrender." Woody Hayes

Calgarybuck's picture

When you cut your teeth vs a future 1st rounder in your first game things seem alot easier the rest of the way :)

Michael Citro's picture

Although I capped my list at six (one player for each game played this season), obviously there are other Buckeyes who have exceeded my expectations this year. You guys have checked most of the boxes of my next group.

If I did an honorable mention section it would consist of: Cameron Johnston, Jamal Marcus, both Grants, Taylor Decker (after a rough first game), Josh Perry and Ezekiel Elliott. Someone mentioned Jordan Hall above. Maybe I was higher on him than most, but J-Hall has given us exactly what I thought he would.

Conroy's picture

Bosa is Cam Heyward 2.0. Giant, incredibly strong DE/DT who makes a big impact as a freshman. Hope he can be as good (or better) than Cam in his next few years at OSU.

CC's picture

I can't imagine Bosa is not better than Cam as a senior when Bosa is a Soph. 

GH_Lindsey's picture

Let's hope he keeps the heyward thing going and adds to the long tradition of freshman OSU DEs destroying "elite" ttun tackles

Kevdaddy8's picture

Great List.  I'd buy stock in Carter.  Another year in our conditioning program where he's focusing on getting stronger and faster rather than losing weight and we are gonna have ourselves something special.  Fact is, it takes a special person to do what he's done already and I for one can't wait to see what the 3.0 version looks like!  I think he takes another big step in the next off season and our D Line is simply unfair.

CentralFloridaBuckeye's picture

Great to see so many of these players step up during the first part of the year.  Bosa has been amazing considering he is just a freshman.  I just imagine what he will be like in a couple of years.  Look out B1G!
Go Bucks!!

Run_Fido_Run's picture

Really good analysis and writing, Michael. 

Brutus's picture

The biggest surprise for me is that Chris Carter is apparently 38. He and Oden must have grown up drinking from the same water supply.

shaggybuckeye's picture

I think Kimbo Slice just decided to play football for Ohio State under a different name.

Buckeye_Mafia's picture

Waiting for the #97 jersey to become available for purchase....looking at you Nike...

"At critical moments throughout the season, we learned about the character of this football team.  This was a team of true character, of true resilience." -- President Barack Obama